No, Governor, Rights Are NOT Government-Issued Privileges That You Can Suspend

On Friday, September 8, Michelle Lujan Grisham, the governor of New Mexico, announced a new public health order suspending the right to carry firearms in Albuquerque and Bernalillo County for at least thirty days.

The New Mexico governor announced the thirty-day suspension at a press conference. Citing the shooting deaths of three children in Albuquerque this summer, Grisham declared “a public health emergency,” which she says gives her the authority to suspend the right to carry firearms in the surrounding county for thirty days.

In front of reporters, Grisham was quick to acknowledge some obvious problems with the order. She admits that the order will not have much of an effect on the level of gun violence in Albuquerque. She instead stressed the symbolism of the measure.

When asked if she really thought that criminals—like those who committed the shootings she cited—would comply and not carry a gun in Albuquerque, Governor Grisham said that she didn’t but thought the motion was a “pretty resounding message.”

Grisham also repeatedly said she expected the motion to be challenged in court. Her demeanor suggested that the entire purpose of the executive order was to spur a legal fight. The governor spent much of the press conference pontificating about a constitutional right to be safe and presented the Second Amendment as incompatible with that right.

Grisham is distorting how rights work to justify her program. She frames rights as a handful of unrelated positive freedoms granted to citizens by the government, which can revoke them during emergencies or when they conflict with rights that government officials deem more important.

In reality, rights are derived from self-ownership. We alone have the highest claim to our own bodies. That right is absolute, so any aggression against our bodies is a rights violation that can be justly resisted or punished proportionately.

And from self-ownership, we can derive the just ownership of property. Self-ownership gives you the highest claim to the fruits of your labor. Unowned resources can justly become owned through homesteading—mixing your labor with unowned natural resources. Once these resources are owned, they can be justly transferred as gifts or through voluntary exchange. Because they are derived from self-ownership, property rights are absolute, meaning any violation can be justly resisted or punished proportionately.

We can see, then, that the right not to be harmed and the right to own property do not conflict—they are variations of the same fundamental right. This is especially evident when the property in question equips us to better protect ourselves and our other property. That’s the case with firearms. The debate Grisham calls for is built on a lie.

The governor is trying to account for the government’s failures to protect people, a service it monopolizes, by violating the property rights of Bernalillo County citizens. She understands this is probably illegal and at the press conference even called herself courageous for moving ahead anyway. Even though, unlike the rest of us outside of government, she wouldn’t face consequences if it were determined that what she’s doing is illegal. She’d, at most, be told to stop.

Or so she thought. Instead, over the weekend, the gun owners of Bernalillo County took to the streets, carrying their weapons peacefully in protest. And the Albuquerque police chief and Bernalillo County sheriff issued statements saying they would not enforce the governor’s order. Because it violates the rights of citizens and draws resources away from preventing real crimes.

That’s real courage.

—

This article appeared first on the Mises Institute under a Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) license.

Image credit: Pexels

5 comments

Connor O'Keeffe

AUTHOR

PROFILE

5 Comments

Rebekah Adams
September 16, 2023, 2:32 pm

There is nothing quite so interesting as putting up a sign, saying gun free zone. Some people see that as safety, but most criminals see that as an invitation to do whatever they want.
- Lauren Gregory@Rebekah Adams
  August 6, 2025, 9:38 am
  
  With joy in my heart and gratitude to God almighty i have come to tell the general public that Lord Gerald herbal medicine is the best remedy for Herpes and HIV/AIDS, I was a carrier of Herpes virus and I saw a testimony on how Lord Gerald cure Herpes, I decided to have a contact with him and asked him for help and he started the remedies for my health and prepare the herbal medicine for me which i use to cure myself. Thank God, now everything is fine, I’m cured by Lord Gerald herbal medicine, I’m very thankful to Lord Gerald and i will not stop publishing his name on the internet because of the good work he did for me, You can reach him on his email: [email protected] or
  WhatsApp: +14242983869
  
  LORD GERALD CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-
  
  1. HIV/AIDS
  2. HERPES
  3. CANCER OF ALL KINDS
  4. HSV
  5. Hepatitis A,B,C
  6. Diabetes
  7. Parkinson’s disease
  8. C.O.P.D
  9.ALS
  10. Coronary Artery Disease (Ischemic Heart Disease)
  11. Alopecia
  12.Bipolar disorder
  13.Bedwetting
  14.Carpal tunnel syndrome
  15.Celiac disease
  16.Ear Infections
  17.Endometriosis
  18.Epilepsy
  19.Chlamydia
  20.Syphilis
  21.Gonorrhea
  
  Natural remedy for curing HERPES and HIV. WhatsApp Lord Gerald on +14242983869
Rand
November 3, 2023, 4:44 am

I believe this was a trial balloon sent aloft to help Democrats devise their legal strategy to be used in the near future to disarm their political opponents. Democrats have a long history of ignoring rulings from the US Supreme Court or any court they do not control. This legal strategy will be used against the American public frequently prior to the next Federal election. My advise, all gun owners should buy as much ammo as they can afford now because that is the next target the Democrats have chosen.
KJo Fink
November 6, 2024, 1:14 pm

Until government actors lose their "sovereign immunity" from prosecution, these kinds of knee-jerk policies will continue. When government agents make decisions knowing they are likely unconstitutional, they should be like the cop on the street – serving 10 years for violating civil rights. The justice system is weaponized because they simply do not respect the Constitution as nothing happens to these governors, attorneys general, etc. Put one or two in jail for a few years and this nonsense will stop.
Lauren Gregory
August 6, 2025, 9:38 am

With joy in my heart and gratitude to God almighty i have come to tell the general public that Lord Gerald herbal medicine is the best remedy for Herpes and HIV/AIDS, I was a carrier of Herpes virus and I saw a testimony on how Lord Gerald cure Herpes, I decided to have a contact with him and asked him for help and he started the remedies for my health and prepare the herbal medicine for me which i use to cure myself. Thank God, now everything is fine, I’m cured by Lord Gerald herbal medicine, I’m very thankful to Lord Gerald and i will not stop publishing his name on the internet because of the good work he did for me, You can reach him on his email: [email protected] or
WhatsApp: +14242983869

LORD GERALD CAN AS WELL CURE THE FOLLOWING DISEASE:-

1. HIV/AIDS
2. HERPES
3. CANCER OF ALL KINDS
4. HSV
5. Hepatitis A,B,C
6. Diabetes
7. Parkinson’s disease
8. C.O.P.D
9.ALS
10. Coronary Artery Disease (Ischemic Heart Disease)
11. Alopecia
12.Bipolar disorder
13.Bedwetting
14.Carpal tunnel syndrome
15.Celiac disease
16.Ear Infections
17.Endometriosis
18.Epilepsy
19.Chlamydia
20.Syphilis
21.Gonorrhea

Natural remedy for curing HERPES and HIV. WhatsApp Lord Gerald on +14242983869