Somewhere, in a conference room adorned with reclaimed barnwood paneling ordered in bulk from a supplier in Shanghai, a well-compensated executive must have declared: For the sake of relevance, we must redesign the Cracker Barrel logo. On and on this executive rambles about “modernity,” “Gen Z, “TikTok,” or whatever corporate buzzword is in fashion now.

The precise sin of the old logo escapes me. Perhaps the gentleman in the rocking chair was deemed insufficiently dynamic, too much at leisure in a culture where every American must be depicted jogging toward a yoga class with a cup the size of a fire extinguisher. What we know for certain is that the new emblem, stripped of all eccentricity, is so algorithmically bland it might as well be advertising a Hampton Inn continental breakfast – which is precisely what the remodeled interiors now resemble. Cracker Barrel once looked like a flea market on amphetamines; now it looks like the holding pen of an urgent care.

When I was marooned for a time in the frigid North, I occasionally braved the snow for Cracker Barrel’s fried catfish. Not because it was great – it was a far cry from Red’s Catfish in Clay County (may it rest in peace). The Almighty may test a man in many ways. Yet for a Southerner stranded north of Knoxville, it sufficed. One cannot live forever on pastrami and pepperoni rolls. Eventually, the Southern heart demands grease, grit, and something that once swam in muddy water.

I suspect this is Cracker Barrel’s true secret: not quality, but familiarity. It is the facsimile of home cooking. The photocopy of a photocopy. Grandmother may be in paradise, slipping butter into St. Peter’s biscuits, but the Barrel offers a warm memory without requiring flour-dusted aprons or scorched skillets. I always assumed the company’s core clientele were precisely those grandparents. These men and women once knew what real greens tasted like but now settle for the fast-casual memory of it.

The difficulty is that nostalgia spoils. I’m not driving an hour to Opelika for cornbread that tastes like damp drywall, no matter how many black and white pictures of John Deere tractors you hang up. The interior redesign accelerates the decay. Congratulations! The one chain that had character has rebranded itself as the waiting room of a Frontier airline gate.

To be fair, returning from a Billy Strings concert in Huntsville last year, I was ambushed by a gift card and found myself once again inside a Cracker Barrel. To my astonishment, the breakfast was … pretty good. Not my Mama or Rob McDaniel’s biscuits, but good enough when consumed in the shadows of a La Quinta Inn and a Walmart Supercenter.

Food was never the Barrel’s genius anyway. Its real distinction lay in the odd touches that showed someone in that outfit still understood its audience. For example: once upon a time, they kept the coldest buttermilk on the planet. I was told that it was for cooking, not serving. But if you found a waitress with a sympathetic soul, she would fetch you a tall glass. In that moment, when hot cornbread was crumbled into frigid buttermilk and eaten with a spoon, Cracker Barrel briefly grazed Valhalla. The last few times I inquired, I was told it wasn’t possible.

As for the logo controversy, I admit to a certain bemusement. I don’t really worry myself about how interstate restaurants decorate their signs. The outrage seems rooted less in the change, but that it represents the hollowing out the last vestiges of uniqueness in American life. We are all to be smoothed, rounded, and corporatized until every roadside establishment looks like every other. Where once you might have encountered a place that looked, smelled, and tasted of a region, you now find yourself eating a chicken-fried steak under the bland gaze of corporate consultants in high water slacks and a quarter zip. In the process of trying to survive, the chain has sacrificed the very peculiarity that made it endearing in the first place. To alienate the customers you still have, while failing to win new ones, is not so much a strategy as a suicide note.

I am not in the business of offering prescriptions to corporate America. But if I were, I might suggest that Cracker Barrel lean into the eccentric rather than flee from it. Keep the buttermilk. Keep the clutter. For goodness’ sake, keep the old man and the barrel. The people who still pull off I-65 to eat there are not doing so for a focus-grouped logo, but because they wish to believe that something of their childhood remains accessible. And if the catfish is only adequate, it is still better than the abomination purveyed by Captain D’s. That attempt at “catfish” would justify mutiny against any captain, nautical or otherwise.

Cracker Barrel’s dilemma is not its logo, but its soul. If it becomes just another beige stopover between Target and Taco Bell, then the Barrel will have rolled itself straight into irrelevance. Better to embrace its own eccentric, slightly shabby charm. Nostalgia may fade. Authenticity endures.

—

The republication of this article is made possible by The Fred & Rheta Skelton Center for Cultural Renewal. 

Image Credit: Flickr-queenkv, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0